There's No Free Lunch - WDAM-TV 7-News, Weather, Sports-Hattiesburg, MS

WDAM-TV Editorial

There's No Free Lunch

WDAM EDITORIAL

THERE'S NO FREE LUNCH

November 20, 2007

All that glitters is not gold.  The last free lunch was the five loaves and two fishes.  Beware unintended consequences.  Ok, ok: enough clichés.  They are all somewhat relevant however, at least in my mind, to State Treasurer Tate Reeves' proposal—based on the semi-socialist system in effect in Great Britain—to give every child born in the state of Mississippi, beginning next year, a $500 savings account.  That would be just the beginning.  More free money could be obtained in subsequent years based on the family's income level.  Hillary Clinton has proposed a similar measure of $5,000 for every child born in the United States. 

It would cost, according to Reeves' estimate, $100 million to implement his plan in Mississippi.  He thinks he can get some of that funded by the private sector—perhaps as much as a quarter.  Frankly, I think that is overly optimistic.  Even so, that still leaves $75 million for the taxpayers to cough up in a state where we have trouble finding money every year to budget for the state's basic needs already.  Look at the struggle every year to fully fund education as just one example.

Under the plan as presented, once the recipient of this money reached 18, at least as I understand it, they would not be obligated to use their free money to pay for an education.  While I have no particular problem with the current state sponsored college savings plan, in general I think the government is a poor choice for managing your money.  Look at Social Security, or the money from liquor tax that was to go toward education but went into the general fund instead.  Additionally,  I'm not keen on the idea of my tax dollars, and yours, going to some 18-year-old who hasn't done a thing to earn them and then getting to decide how they are going to spend this windfall. 

Hopefully, the legislature and the governor will look at this well-meaning, but fraught with peril, idea long and hard before passing it.  It would be wonderful if we lived in a world where we could just end poverty by giving everyone money.  I think most would agree that governmental attempts to do just that have generally not worked out well in the long term for anyone.  It also runs contrary to the American ideal of people taking responsibility for their own success instead of looking to Big Brother for their needs.  Charity is perhaps the greatest virtue of all.  Misguided and forced redistribution sets off a world of unintended consequences that we can ill afford. 

I'm Jim Cameron. Let us know what you think.

 

  • Local NewsLOCALMore>>

  • Hearing set for former MS teacher accused of running away with student

    Hearing set for former MS teacher accused of running away with student

    Tuesday, June 19 2018 7:21 PM EDT2018-06-19 23:21:43 GMT
    A hearing has been set for Nicole Jackson, a former Forrest County school teacher who was at the center of an investigation involving a missing Hattiesburg teen. (Photo source: HPD)A hearing has been set for Nicole Jackson, a former Forrest County school teacher who was at the center of an investigation involving a missing Hattiesburg teen. (Photo source: HPD)
    A hearing has been set for Nicole Jackson, a former Forrest County school teacher who was at the center of an investigation involving a missing Hattiesburg teen. (Photo source: HPD)A hearing has been set for Nicole Jackson, a former Forrest County school teacher who was at the center of an investigation involving a missing Hattiesburg teen. (Photo source: HPD)
    A hearing has been set for a former Forrest County school teacher who was at the center of an investigation involving a missing Hattiesburg teen. The motion hearing for Nicole Jackson is set for July 2 in Circuit Court after turning herself in on June 14.  Jackson is behind bars at the Forrest County Jail charged with contributing to the delinquency of a minor and contempt of court. She is also facing a previous charge of sexual battery by a person in a position ...More >>
    A hearing has been set for a former Forrest County school teacher who was at the center of an investigation involving a missing Hattiesburg teen. The motion hearing for Nicole Jackson is set for July 2 in Circuit Court after turning herself in on June 14.  Jackson is behind bars at the Forrest County Jail charged with contributing to the delinquency of a minor and contempt of court. She is also facing a previous charge of sexual battery by a person in a position ...More >>
  • Forrest County board approves paving project

    Forrest County board approves paving project

    Tuesday, June 19 2018 6:49 PM EDT2018-06-19 22:49:31 GMT
    Forrest County Board of Supervisors President David Hogan said the total approximate cost of the project will be around $300,000. (Photo source: WDAM archive)Forrest County Board of Supervisors President David Hogan said the total approximate cost of the project will be around $300,000. (Photo source: WDAM archive)

    The Forrest County Board of Supervisors recently approved a paving project that reaches inside the city limits of Hattiesburg. The projects include a stretch of Jackson Road that runs from Rawls Springs Loop Road to near the Longleaf Trace Jackson Station and another at Sullivan Kilrain Road North of Highway 11, which extends all the way to the railroad tracks at the Lamar County line. “50 percent of the road and bridge taxes that are collected gets split betwee...

    More >>

    The Forrest County Board of Supervisors recently approved a paving project that reaches inside the city limits of Hattiesburg. The projects include a stretch of Jackson Road that runs from Rawls Springs Loop Road to near the Longleaf Trace Jackson Station and another at Sullivan Kilrain Road North of Highway 11, which extends all the way to the railroad tracks at the Lamar County line. “50 percent of the road and bridge taxes that are collected gets split betwee...

    More >>
  • MAC Coaches Hall of Fame to be held in Jackson

    MAC Coaches Hall of Fame to be held in Jackson

    Tuesday, June 19 2018 6:49 PM EDT2018-06-19 22:49:17 GMT
    The 46th Annual Mississippi Association of Coaches Hall of Fame Induction and Awards Banquet will be held in Jackson later this week. (Photo source: mscoaches.com)The 46th Annual Mississippi Association of Coaches Hall of Fame Induction and Awards Banquet will be held in Jackson later this week. (Photo source: mscoaches.com)

    The 46th Annual Mississippi Association of Coaches Hall of Fame Induction and Awards Banquet will be held in Jackson later this week.  The banquet, sponsored by BankPlus, will be held on Friday, June 22, at 6 p.m. at the Hilton Hotel off County Line Road and I-55 North, according to a MAC press release. Created in 1973, the 2018 induction class will increase the Hall of Fame's membership to 237 members.  The MAC Hall of Fame Class of 2018 includes:   NEVIL...

    More >>

    The 46th Annual Mississippi Association of Coaches Hall of Fame Induction and Awards Banquet will be held in Jackson later this week.  The banquet, sponsored by BankPlus, will be held on Friday, June 22, at 6 p.m. at the Hilton Hotel off County Line Road and I-55 North, according to a MAC press release. Created in 1973, the 2018 induction class will increase the Hall of Fame's membership to 237 members.  The MAC Hall of Fame Class of 2018 includes:   NEVIL...

    More >>
Powered by Frankly