Kavanagh tones down anti-discrimination amendment - WDAM-TV 7-News, Weather, Sports-Hattiesburg, MS

Kavanagh tones down anti-discrimination amendment

PHOENIX (CBS5) -

Rep. John Kavanagh (R-District 8) plans to introduce a new amendment to a bill that would effectively restrict part of the new anti-discrimination laws that Phoenix City Council passed this February.

The new law would replace the amendment Kavanagh proposed late last week, which would criminalize someone using a restroom of the sex not listed on their birth certificate.

"I've actually taken an entirely different tactic," explained Kavanagh.

"Some members (of the Arizona House of Representatives and state Senate) were concerned that I was expanding criminal law to deal with this issue," he continued.

Under the previous bill, SB 1432, people could be charged with a misdemeanor for disorderly conduct if they used the incorrect bathroom. The deciding factor would have been what was written on their birth certificate.

That amendment caused controversy with the transgender community. Many of its members showed up for Wednesday's House Appropriations Committee hearing, but that hearing was postponed.

The new bill would not criminalize restroom use. Rather, Kavanagh said, it would prevent municipalities from making it a crime or allowing a lawsuit against a business that restricts someone from using a bathroom, changing room or dressing area.

"I'm going to simply take the law back to the day before Phoenix passed (its latest laws) and simply state that these areas where there is an expectation of privacy based on gender are off limits to government tinkering, criminalizing and lawsuits."

Phoenix's newly passed ordinance would allow transgender people to use the bathroom of their choice. Business owners could be sued civilly if someone claimed they were discriminated against and not allowed to use a certain restroom.

"Government can't say to a business, 'If you want to have a separate men's room and a separate women's room, you're under arrest and we're suing you.' That's ridiculous," said Kavanagh.

Those who disagree with Kavanagh's amended bill said they're closely watching the changes.

"I think there are some serious constitutional questions at play," stated Anjali Abraham, a policy director for the American Civil Liberties Union of Arizona. 

"Clearly the intent of the amendment is to undo what the Phoenix City Council did very recently in terms of expanding its protections against discrimination to certain groups that have traditionally experienced a lot of discrimination and harassment," she continued.

Abraham believes the amended bill is unconstitutional and could be challenged in court if passed.

"When you have a City Council that has expanded its protections in terms of protecting people from discrimination, the state faces a really high bar in trying to undue that. This legislation does not meet that high bar at all," she stated.

The amended bill is expected to be heard during Wednesday's House Appropriations Committee hearing.

Copyright 2013 CBS 5 (KPHO Broadcasting Corporation). All rights reserved.

  • Local NewsLOCALMore>>

  • Kool Smiles hosts 4th annual Sharing Smiles Day

    Kool Smiles hosts 4th annual Sharing Smiles Day

    Sunday, May 20 2018 6:59 PM EDT2018-05-20 22:59:39 GMT
    source: wdamsource: wdam
    source: wdamsource: wdam

    Children in Hattiesburg and surrounding areas were able to get free dental care during Kool Smiles 4th annual "Sharing Smiles Day" Sunday morning.

    More >>

    Children in Hattiesburg and surrounding areas were able to get free dental care during Kool Smiles 4th annual "Sharing Smiles Day" Sunday morning.

    More >>
  • The Flower Bed Nursery hosts 3rd annual Family Day

    The Flower Bed Nursery hosts 3rd annual Family Day

    Sunday, May 20 2018 6:49 PM EDT2018-05-20 22:49:25 GMT
    source: wdamsource: wdam
    source: wdamsource: wdam

    The Flower Bed Nursery in Lumberton hosted its 3rd annual spring Family Day Sunday, May 20.

    More >>

    The Flower Bed Nursery in Lumberton hosted its 3rd annual spring Family Day Sunday, May 20.

    More >>
  • USM's Tori Bowie wins 100m title at Adidas Boost Boston Games

    USM's Tori Bowie wins 100m title at Adidas Boost Boston Games

    Sunday, May 20 2018 2:51 PM EDT2018-05-20 18:51:14 GMT
    On Sunday, Tori Bowie won the 100m race at the 2018 Adidas Boost Boston Games. (Photo Source: Adidas Boost Boston Games)On Sunday, Tori Bowie won the 100m race at the 2018 Adidas Boost Boston Games. (Photo Source: Adidas Boost Boston Games)

    With a run time of 11:05, Torie Bowie is the 2018 Adidas Boost Boston Games 100m champion. The race took place Sunday just after 2:00 p.m. on Charles Street in Boston.  "I was really excited about the race," said Bowie just moments after her win.  There's no stopping @toribowie! After her world record 150m last year, she takes the win in the 100m this year. 11.05 for Bowie FTW.#TakeChargeBoston pic.twitter.com/9HSdeWcTn8 — adidas Boost Boston (@a...

    More >>

    With a run time of 11:05, Torie Bowie is the 2018 Adidas Boost Boston Games 100m champion. The race took place Sunday just after 2:00 p.m. on Charles Street in Boston.  "I was really excited about the race," said Bowie just moments after her win.  There's no stopping @toribowie! After her world record 150m last year, she takes the win in the 100m this year. 11.05 for Bowie FTW.#TakeChargeBoston pic.twitter.com/9HSdeWcTn8 — adidas Boost Boston (@a...

    More >>
Powered by Frankly